Reels vs TikTok vs Shorts: on which one must you guess to your paid UA marketing campaign?

TikTok’s success appears unstoppable. With a rising variety of downloads and common customers, the video app grew a lot that its direct opponents adopted TikTok-like options of their platforms. 

Whereas video advertisements are, and have been for a while, a staple of UA campaigns, there’s now extra selection than ever on the place to promote your app or cell sport. When you’re seeking to promote on social media platforms, TikTok, Instagram Reels, and YouTube Shorts are all related options. However which one would be the only? 

Making the appropriate selection to your app

Though it was attainable up till just lately to arrange video advert campaigns on social media with out together with TikTok, Reels, or Shorts, it’s not the case anymore. In fact, there are different advert placements (in Meta and YouTube) the place you possibly can showcase a video advert, however these three platforms/instruments are actually a necessary a part of UA campaigns, particularly with the rise of demand for UGC-like video advertisements.

All three choices could look alike however they every have a distinct impression and viewers. 

In fact, the extra the merrier. When you’re in a position to promote your app on all three platforms (with content material created to match these platforms’ expectations and viewers) you should have the absolute best consequence. However typically, selections must be made. 

There isn’t any one resolution that matches everybody on this state of affairs, every app, and every characteristic has its personal viewers, wants, and outcomes and can work greatest relying on the content material you possibly can produce for it and the goal you plan to succeed in.

supply: The Graygency

To this point, Instagram has probably the most month-to-month energetic customers however TikTok is the one which’s rising sooner. YouTube Shorts can depend on YouTube’s highly effective advert attain and its older viewers, in addition to the truth that the platform is and all the time has been about video. 

Whichever platform you find yourself selecting, all of them have their benefits and wishes. YouTube will want much less adjustment (Google is now even beta-testing an computerized crop of video advertisements to incorporate on Shorts), however Shorts is but to be a cultural phenomenon as important as TikTok or Instagram Reels. TikTok is rising quick and has big potential for model consciousness and discovery with distinctive attain, nevertheless it solely works with video advertisements tailor-made to TikTok’s particular viewers and content material. In the meantime, Instagram’s advert system is well-oiled and works properly with a big viewers, and Meta’s promoting system to again it up, however customers are nonetheless pushing again on the app’s (perhaps too) agency push of Reels. 

Step one is to set your marketing campaign’s expectations and KPIs, then determine which platform is the very best that can assist you attain these targets.  

TikTok advertisements: the place to be for cell video games and Gen Z

TikTok is a beacon for youthful customers. Now, 74% of TikTok’s customers are beneath 35. With over a billion month-to-month energetic customers and a excessive engagement price, TikTok is a extremely attention-grabbing place to promote your app or sport. 

Given its newness (and regardless of its rising recognition), advertisers have been reluctant to strive their fingers at TikTok promoting at first. This led the platform to spice up its promoting choices, particularly for cell gaming. With Apple’s ATT nonetheless impacting Meta and Snap’s outcomes in addition to Twitter’s unstable future, a number of advertisers are actually TikTok for his or her future UA spending.

Much more so once you check out TikTok’s engagement price, which is extraordinarily excessive, particularly in contrast with their direct opponents.

supply: The platforms’ engagement price

TikTok’s engagement and thunderous success around the globe are nice incentives for app builders. It’s an incredible alternative for UA campaigns, so long as the video creatives look sufficient like TikToks. The model’s motto regarding promoting is: “Make TikToks not advertisements”.

As a result of video advertisements are inserted seamlessly into the scrolling feed of customers, the simplest advert campaigns are those that don’t seem like advertisements at first look. 

TikTok will be your UA technique’s greatest pal so long as your advert can match throughout the app’s natural content material. It’s additionally an incredible selection for cell sport promoting. A number of video games (like Excessive Heels or extra just lately have discovered international success because of TikTok campaigns). 

The corporate’s push into cell gaming, by means of promoting alternatives and catering to gaming audiences, makes it a really related device for cell gaming advert campaigns. 

What works greatest on TikTok

  • UGC-type advertisements (for extra particulars on learn how to make the most of UGC developments try our submit on the subject)
  • Reside-action works greatest, it suits higher within the feed of individuals’s for you web page 
  • Music and voice-over are extraordinarily necessary, a number of TikTok’s success depends on its sound use
  • An advert that matches the app’s present development, which implies a fast manufacturing of advert creatives
  • Cell video games: TikTok is a superb platform to advertise cell video games

Instagram Reels: Millennials’ favourite

Instagram is a well-oiled machine that depends on Meta’s sturdy promoting system. Whereas Reels promoting continues to be a fairly current addition to the platform, it’s a format that Instagram has been pushing closely as of late and with Reels taking increasingly house on the platform, it might quickly be probably the most seen kind of promoting on Instagram. 

Mark Zuckerberg introduced that 20% of customers’ time on Instagram was spent scrolling by means of Reels. A whole lot of Reels are nonetheless reused from TikTok (a number of TikTokers joke about the truth that TikTok developments present up a couple of months afterward Instagram Reels). 

Reels should be struggling to meet up with TikTok nevertheless it’s nonetheless a related choice. 

The most effective half about Reels is that it will probably match seamlessly right into a extra normal Meta advert marketing campaign, with static creatives within the feed or Tales. Customers who use each Fb and Instagram may even encounter them on each networks, bettering model recall. 

Meta’s advert system has additionally been in place for a couple of years already and has been working fairly properly for advertisers previously. Instagram’s consumer base is extra regular than TikTok’s (who’s rising very quickly however continues to be fairly current). Nonetheless, Meta obtained hit exhausting by ATT so concentrating on is probably not as environment friendly now. 

Instagram Reels shouldn’t be having outcomes nearly as good as TikTok up to now when it comes to utilization, nevertheless it’s a safer choice for promoting with a extra female, barely older consumer base that’s extra used to advert presence. 

For instance, Creatopia’s case research reveals higher outcomes with the identical marketing campaign launched on each Reels and TikTok.

Nonetheless, a marketing campaign that works on one platform is probably not an excellent match for an additional one, every one having a distinct viewers. Additionally, the model had an already established Instagram account, with a robust presence which may add some model consciousness. The TikTok account used was model new. 

What works greatest on Instagram:

  • Aesthetic content material, your advert must look good sufficient to be taken significantly on this medium
  • Utilizing related or stylish audio sounds (it additionally improves the advert’s visibility)
  • Authenticity and honesty
  • Give attention to constructing model picture and consciousness
  • Captions in movies
  • Content material that feels natural and appears like common Reels content material
  • Dynamic and informative content material
  • Behind the scenes and explainers
  • Brief advert copy straight displaying on the video

YouTube Shorts: Google’s newest device

YouTube Shorts is Google’s reply to TikTok’s success. The brand new tab will be discovered within the YouTube app and on the web site. Now each vertical video shared on YouTube is being become a Shorts mechanically. 

In keeping with Google, YouTube Shorts obtain 15 billion each day views, which is kind of a feat. The characteristic undoubtedly takes benefit of its connection to YouTube and the truth that over 70% of YouTube’s watch time occurs on cell. 

Shorts has the bottom engagement price of all three and is globally much less used than each Reels and TikTok. Nonetheless, the characteristic’s greatest success price appears to be in nations the place TikTok has been banned.

Google is already planning to spice up Shorts’ advert choice, first with a brand new creator fund that rewards shorts creators to drive extra consideration and engagement, but in addition they’re testing an computerized crop of YouTube advertisements to point out them in Shorts in the very best format (portrait). 

It at present isn’t straightforward to create advertisements solely for Shorts nevertheless, it may be included in a YouTube advert marketing campaign. 

Until you’re in a area the place TikTok shouldn’t be obtainable, Shorts is extra, up to now, an additional device to a normal YouTube or Google advert marketing campaign. Or in case your viewers matches higher with YouTube’s consumer base. Shorts shouldn’t be as profitable and culturally related as Reels and TikTok simply but, it is also newer so it nonetheless has time to develop. 

What works greatest on YouTube Shorts

  • YouTube Shorts is extraordinarily profitable in nations the place TikTok is banned like India for instance, when you’re concentrating on this locale, it may be an incredible selection for you
  • Brief movies, YouTube Shorts has not but prolonged the size of its movies not like Instagram and TikTok
  • A powerful name to motion

Your best option is dependent upon what you’re in search of

The most suitable choice is to create a video advert based on the platform you’re concentrating on. Nonetheless, it’s all the time attainable to reuse an advert, it might be higher to create an advert for TikTok which has probably the most particular wants when it comes to related content material, after which convey it to both Reels (to finish an Instagram UA technique) or Shorts. 

Extra channels means extra alternatives, however every one will convey its personal set of strengths and weaknesses. Each Reels and Brief depend on stronger advert methods (Meta and Google) and have already got a strong consumer base, however TikTok is extra culturally related with a task of trendsetting that retains rising on-line. 

Set your expectations first, then you possibly can look into which platform would be the extra acceptable that can assist you obtain them.

Newest posts by Marine Nozerand (see all)

Related Articles


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Latest Articles